Five years after euthanasia became legal in New Zealand, official records reveal a growing service, concerns about safeguards, gaps in public reporting and uncertainty about the future of the legislation. An examination of the figures, investigations and experiences behind the law raises fundamental questions about its operation and oversight.
In November 2026, New Zealand marked five years since the End of Life Choice Act came into force.
It is a milestone that deserves scrutiny rather than celebration.
By 31 March 2026, 1,696 people had died by euthanasia or assisted suicide, and 4,077 people had applied for assisted dying under the End of Life Choice Act.
Since the first full reporting year in 2022/23, annual applications for euthanasia and assisted suicide have increased by 44%, from 807 to 1,164 in 2025/26, while assisted deaths have increased by 48%, from 328 to 486.
Assisted deaths now account for 1.29% of all registered deaths in New Zealand — approximately one in every 78 deaths.
The demographic profile of applicants has remained relatively stable over the five years. In 2025/26, four out of every five applicants (80%) were aged 65 or older, while 81% identified as New Zealand European. Māori accounted for approximately 5% of applicants.
Cancer remains the leading diagnosis, accounting for 63% of applications.
Across the five reporting periods, no applicants were recorded as being under the age of 18.
Roughly one in five applicants was not receiving palliative care at the time of application. In 2025/26 alone, 238 applicants fell into this category.
That represents nearly 240 people in a single year seeking state-administered death without the health system first having provided the care intended to relieve suffering that the Act treats as a qualifying criterion and to improve quality of life.
The proportion of euthanasia occurring in aged-care facilities has nearly doubled, with around one in five now taking place in these settings. Private residences remain the most common location, accounting for 69.8% of assisted deaths in the latest reporting period.
The reporting suggests a shift from institutional reluctance towards greater accommodation of assisted dying. The 2022 report noted that allowing assisted deaths was “a complex decision” for community providers, while the 2022/23 complaint records included practitioners reporting that facilities were obstructive or inadequately accommodating. By 2024/25, one in five assisted deaths was occurring within these facilities.
Unlike a private home, an aged-care facility is a communal residence for frail older people — the very population at the centre of concerns about safeguards under this law. Residents therefore live alongside the euthanasia service being provided. What changed in facility policies or practices to account for this increase is a question the reports do not answer.
Consistent with trends in other international jurisdictions that permit both euthanasia and assisted suicide, nearly 94% of assisted deaths in New Zealand have been by euthanasia, where a practitioner administers the lethal drugs. This proportion has continued to increase. In the latest reporting period, 460 of the 486 assisted deaths were by euthanasia rather than assisted suicide.
This pattern raises a question the reports do not address: why do approximately 19 out of 20 people who qualify for assisted dying leave the final act to a clinician? Voice For Life believes that practitioner administration transfers the decisive act — and its moral weight — from the patient to the doctor, cloaking euthanasia in the white coat of medical legitimacy.
Annual reports have progressively disclosed less information. The 2024 report omitted all workforce data, while the 2026 report was the first to omit figures for Official Information Act (OIA) requests, media queries and parliamentary questions — following a year in which OIA requests had increased by 457%. Training-completion statistics have not been published since 2023.
Health New Zealand originally published quarterly assisted-dying service reports, despite having no legal obligation to do so. However, over the past 18 months, these reports have progressively disappeared from public view on official websites.
Their withdrawal represents the loss of an additional layer of public transparency, leaving the statutory annual report as the only guaranteed source of regular public reporting on the assisted-dying system.
The Medical Industry Bears the Brunt
Behind the rising number of assisted deaths is a medical workforce responsible for assessing eligibility, administering lethal medication and navigating the ethical and practical challenges of assisted dying.
Official figures, independent research, and interviews with New Zealand clinicians reveal growing pressures, a concentration of euthanasia provision among a small number of practitioners, and serious concerns about the impact on patients and healthcare professionals.
The number of practitioners listed with Support and Consultation for End of Life in New Zealand (SCENZ) reached 148 in 2023 but had fallen to 121 by 2026 — an 18.2% reduction. Over the same period, the annual number of assisted deaths per listed practitioner increased by 81%, from 2.2 to 4.0.
Although more than a hundred practitioners remain listed, the majority of deaths are concentrated among a relatively small number.
Information obtained under the Official Information Act reveals that, in the year ending March 2026, just ten practitioners were involved in 196 euthanasia deaths, receiving a combined $907,764 in publicly funded fees, excluding travel payments. The highest-volume practitioner was associated with 34 assisted deaths in that single year and received $136,267.59 for euthanasia services alone.
Meanwhile, the number of listed psychiatrists fell from 13 in 2023 to just three nationwide in 2026, with none in the Midland or Central regions.
Through confidential interviews with three senior New Zealand clinicians, Voice For Life has documented accounts raising serious concerns about patient vulnerability, financial pressures, clinical judgement and the treatment of healthcare workers who object to euthanasia.
These are not hypothetical scenarios. They are experiences described by healthcare professionals working within New Zealand's euthanasia system.
A Patient Who Could Not Afford the Care He Needed
In March 2026, Voice For Life published an interview with a senior clinician at one of New Zealand's major tertiary hospitals.
He described the case of an older man with a progressive illness who had previously been living independently and enjoying a good quality of life. Following a sudden loss of mobility, the man could no longer return home without substantial assistance.
Although he was not experiencing significant pain, he began discussing euthanasia.
The clinician was concerned that the man had not been given sufficient time to adjust to his changed circumstances. More troublingly, when he asked whether adequate home-care support would change the man's decision, both the patient and his wife reportedly indicated that it would.
The couple could not afford the level of care required for him to return home.
For the clinician, this raised a fundamental concern: was the patient seeking death because his suffering was truly beyond relief, or because the support he needed to continue living was financially out of reach?
The clinician's concerns extended beyond the circumstances influencing patients' decisions. In the same interview, he described three cases that had caused workplace difficulties, particularly around communication, conscientious objection and staff involvement.
Although external practitioners were brought in to administer euthanasia deaths, other staff reportedly remained involved in the patient’s euthanasia because alternative personnel were not available. Its impact on them was significant.
The clinician questioned how assisted dying was changing the medical profession: “I just don't understand how we got here — how we got to the point where doctors are killing their patients. What happened to us?”
He also described the moral distress experienced by healthcare professionals who object to assisted dying: “To have moral distress in this situation is actually normal. If that dies in me, something bad has gone wrong.”
His account highlights the difference between legal conscientious-objection protections and the practical challenges of maintaining those boundaries in a collaborative healthcare environment.
When Eligibility Depends on Which Doctor You Ask
A second senior palliative-care doctor interviewed by Voice For Life raised concerns about how consistently practitioners interpret the End of Life Choice Act's eligibility requirements.
She questioned the reliability of assessments involving concepts such as unbearable suffering and a prognosis of six months or less.
Even experienced specialists, she explained, can disagree about how long a patient is likely to live.
She described a colleague who became involved in the assisted-dying service partly because she feared other practitioners might apply the law less carefully.
The doctor also raised concerns about pressure on clinicians to approve assisted-dying requests, particularly when eligibility assessments depend on individual interpretations of suffering and prognosis.
Her concerns extended beyond eligibility assessments to the circumstances influencing patients' wishes to die.
She recalled a patient living with a severe neurological illness whose greatest fear was becoming invisible and being regarded as a burden.
For the doctor, the danger was that dependence, disability and fear of burdening others could increasingly become associated with reasons for seeking death rather than reasons for providing greater care.
These accounts raise a profound question: when a person fears becoming dependent on others, is death an appropriate response to that fear?
The same doctor described a hospice patient who had received care over many months before dying unexpectedly.
Staff initially assumed the patient's illness had progressed rapidly. Only later, after seeing a death notice, did they discover that the patient had undergone assisted dying.
The doctor described the distress experienced by nurses who had invested considerable time and care in their patients, only to discover afterwards that their lives had ended through euthanasia.
Some staff felt rejected. Others struggled with the knowledge that a patient they had been caring for had chosen to end their life without their involvement.
The account illustrates how assisted dying can affect not only the patient and family but also the healthcare workers who have formed longstanding relationships with them.
Behind Closed Doors: What Practitioners Experienced
Concerns about clinical judgement, practitioner preparedness, and the administration of assisted dying also emerged from research conducted by the University of Auckland, published in May 2025.
The study involved interviews with 22 practitioners who directly participated in euthanasia during the law's first year of operation, offering insight into the practical and ethical challenges encountered by those providing the service.
Assessing Eligibility and Identifying Coercion
Practitioners described difficulties assessing patients they had never previously met, particularly when they had limited opportunities to understand their medical history, family relationships, psychological circumstances and reasons for requesting euthanasia.
In some cases, family members acted as the principal point of contact rather than the patient, complicating efforts to determine whether the request genuinely reflected the patient's own wishes.
One practitioner also described patients who had spent their lives being highly independent and found the prospect of losing control terrifying. Many were accustomed to managing their own lives and struggled with the prospect of depending on others.
These experiences raise questions about the reliability of eligibility assessments, particularly when practitioners have limited knowledge of a patient's circumstances or opportunities to identify external pressures.
Complications During Assisted Deaths
The research also documented complications during the administration of assisted-dying medication.
One practitioner described patients experiencing prolonged distress after taking oral medication, including gagging, choking and difficulty breathing. In some instances, the process reportedly lasted 15–30 minutes.
Other practitioners described difficulties administering intravenous medication because patients' veins were damaged, dehydrated or difficult to access, sometimes following chemotherapy or other treatments.
In some cases, practitioners had to switch methods or wait for alternative medication to become available.
These experiences challenge the assumption that euthanasia is invariably a quick, predictable and comfortable medical procedure. They also raise questions about how patients and families are prepared for the possibility of complications and how such incidents are documented and reviewed.
Concerns About Independent Witnesses and Accountability
Another practitioner involved in the research raised concerns about being alone when administering the lethal drugs.
The doctor feared that if a family member subsequently alleged misconduct, there might be no independent witness to corroborate what had occurred.
Although the concern was expressed from the practitioner's perspective, its implications extend to patient protection.
If questions arise about a patient's final consent, the circumstances of medication administration or events immediately before death, what independent evidence is available to establish what happened?
This is particularly significant because the patient is no longer alive to provide their own account.
Read more about the impacts on healthcare here:
Voice for Life — Senior Hospital Clinician Speaks Out on Assisted Dying
Voice for Life — Why Didn't You Want Us to Help? Senior Palliative Care Doctor Speaks Out
Voice for Life — The Hidden Truth About Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide in NZ
Voice for Life — Highest Number of Assisted Deaths on Record, Yet Still Not Enough for the ACT Party
Accountability: When Safeguards Fail
The Ministry's Three-Year Review: Unresolved Safeguards
In November 2024, the Ministry of Health published its first legally required review of the End of Life Choice Act, three years after assisted dying became legal in New Zealand.
Under section 30 of the Act, the Ministry was required to examine how the legislation was operating and report its findings to Parliament.
Its findings identified significant weaknesses in the legal framework governing euthanasia deaths. Most concerningly, the review identified limitations affecting the very organisations responsible for ensuring the law was being followed.
The resulting 166-page document contained recommendations in principle for legislative change covering safeguards, practitioner responsibilities, criminal enforcement, oversight, and workforce training.
The Ministry acknowledged that the Registrar lacked explicit powers to fulfil its safeguarding role and that the End of Life Review Committee was unable to operate as an effective oversight body within its existing scope.
These were not minor administrative concerns. They related directly to the system's ability to assess compliance, examine the circumstances surrounding assisted deaths, and respond when requirements were not met.
However, not all the recommendations were designed to strengthen safeguards. Several would make assisted dying easier to access or integrate more extensively into the healthcare system.
That distinction matters; proposals intended to increase access should not be presented as equivalent to proposals addressing deficiencies in oversight, consent or legal accountability.
The recommendations were not subsequently subjected to formal assessment or further consultation with practitioners working within the system. They should therefore be treated as proposals warranting further investigation, consultation and research, rather than as established solutions to the weaknesses identified.
Two Oversight Committee Members Raise the Alarm
Two inaugural members of New Zealand's End of Life Review Committee raised serious concerns that the country's euthanasia oversight system was so limited it could fail to detect unlawful deaths.
In an NZ Herald investigation published on 9 October 2024, palliative-care specialist Dr Jane Greville and medical ethics expert Dr Dana Wensley revealed that the committee tasked with reviewing euthanasia deaths was routinely denied access to information needed to properly scrutinise cases.
The three-member committee was responsible for examining reports of euthanasia and assisted suicide deaths and identifying possible breaches of the End of Life Choice Act. Yet members were not provided with basic clinical details, including patients' diagnoses, prognoses, assessments of decision-making capacity, or information relevant to identifying coercion. Even the time lethal drugs were administered was absent from reports.
Greville said information she obtained informally from doctors sometimes contradicted the official reports, but the committee had no authority to investigate those discrepancies.
“We have been unable to explore these sometimes jarring inconsistencies.”
One particularly concerning case involved a patient suspected of having frontal dementia who did not speak English but was approved for euthanasia without an interpreter present during the assessment. Greville said a recommendation concerning interpreters was not accepted because the matter fell outside the committee's remit.
In a letter to Health Minister Shane Reti, Greville described the committee as having been “constrained to the point of irrelevance”.
“These are decisions of life and death,” she warned. “Without adequate review, the processes and the practitioners are extremely vulnerable.”
Both inaugural members subsequently left the committee, although under different circumstances.
Wensley resigned when her two-year term ended in October 2023, after the Ministry instructed reviewers to assume there were no issues when sections of euthanasia reports appeared blank. She considered the instruction contrary to best practice.
Greville, who had applied for reappointment in May 2023, was informed in March 2024 that her term would not be extended. No official reason for her non-renewal was established in the reporting.
Their departures also exposed a significant interruption to independent oversight. Following Wensley's resignation in October 2023, the End of Life Review Committee effectively ceased operating for several months.
According to Greville, no euthanasia-death reports were signed off by the committee between November 2023 and March 2024.
Although the Registrar continued reviewing cases, the additional layer of independent scrutiny required under the Act was absent during this period.
The Ministry subsequently confirmed that the committee's work did not resume until new appointments were made in mid-2024, leaving a backlog of euthanasia-death reports that were reviewed retrospectively.
Complaints and Findings of Non-Compliance
Across the five reporting periods, 63 complaints were recorded, raising concerns about patients' competence to consent, health practitioners allegedly initiating discussions about euthanasia and assisted suicide without being asked, inadequate bereavement support for families, and the conduct of healthcare professionals.
The Registrar also recorded 12 findings of non-compliance across the complete reporting years. However, the published figures do not establish the seriousness or nature of each finding, nor whether they involved the same types of procedural failures.
The Registrar is responsible for reviewing compliance with the Act before an assisted death may proceed.
Five years after the End of Life Choice Act came into force, serious questions remain about whether its safeguards can reliably prevent unlawful euthanasia deaths, detect breaches and hold practitioners accountable.
An Assisted Death Without the Legally Required Review
A Voice For Life investigation, based on official government documents, uncovered a case in which a doctor carried out euthanasia without the mandatory Registrar compliance review, using expired lethal medication prescribed for another patient.
In March 2024, a New Zealand doctor administered euthanasia to a patient before the Registrar had completed the legally required compliance review. The failure was discovered the following day, when a Health New Zealand clinical advisor contacted the doctor seeking outstanding paperwork. The advisor believed the application was still progressing.
The doctor replied that the patient had already died.
Further enquiries established that no lethal medication had been prescribed for that patient. Instead, the doctor had used a drug kit originally supplied for another patient more than eight weeks earlier.
The medication had expired and still carried the other patient's identifying information.
The case was referred to the Police, the Health and Disability Commissioner and the Medical Council of New Zealand.
The central safeguard intended to prevent an assisted death from proceeding without the required checks had failed — and the failure was only identified after the death.
Despite a Police investigation, no criminal charges followed. In correspondence dated 5 October 2026, Police told Voice For Life: “Police determined that it was not in the public interest to lay charges in relation to this matter and subsequently filed the investigation.”
Under section 39 of the End of Life Choice Act, a medical practitioner, nurse practitioner or psychiatrist commits an offence if they wilfully fail to comply with a requirement of the Act. The maximum penalty is three months' imprisonment, a $10,000 fine, or both.
The Ministry of Health's own 2024 legislative review acknowledged weaknesses in this framework, noting that the law does not clearly distinguish between minor administrative failures and serious breaches of essential safeguards.
Failures in the Management of Lethal Medication
The investigation also exposed wider failures in the management of medication specifically supplied to end human lives.
Health New Zealand's internal review found weaknesses in the procedures for monitoring and reconciling unused lethal drug kits.
At the time, there was no formal standard requiring the kits to be returned within 14 days, despite that being the expected timeframe.
A six-month audit revealed the scale of the problem.
Only 13.5% of kits supplied through one dispensing pharmacy and 33.59% through another were returned within 14 days.
Following the incident, Health New Zealand introduced changes to drug monitoring, return procedures, compliance reporting and escalation of overdue kits. But the latest figures still showed that nearly one in five kits were returned late.
Read More on Accountability and Oversight Here:
Voice For Life — Investigation: NZ Doctor Performed Euthanasia Without Legally Required Review
NZ Herald, Isaac Davison, 9 October 2024, Assisted dying in NZ: Reviewers say oversight is so limited that wrongful deaths could go undetected. Original article supplied for this review.
Maxim Institute, Euthanising Oversight: https://www.maxim.org.nz/article/euthanising-oversight/
Journal of Medical Ethics — Research on the moral impact of assisted dying
Ministry of Health, Registrar (Assisted Dying) Annual Report: https://www.health.govt.nz/system/files/2025-07/registrar-assisted-dying-annual-report-to-the-minister-of-health-online-v3.pdf
Ministry of Health — Current End of Life Review Committee powers.
Ministry of Health — Legislative review and Government response.
ACT — Proposed End of Life Choice Amendment Bill (August 2025).
The Push for Expansion: Where Is the Law Heading?
Five years after New Zealand legalised assisted dying, the push to expand euthanasia is already underway, driven by advocacy groups and the ACT Party.
The End-of-Life Choice Society has continued campaigning for broader access, working alongside ACT MP Todd Stephenson as he seeks to change the law. This relationship was particularly apparent at ACT public meetings in the lead-up to the 2026 election, where Society representatives attended in support of Stephenson's proposals and, at times, answered questions from members of the public about the legislation.
In January 2026, Voice For Life published its investigation, Exposed: Dangerous Euthanasia Expansion Law Veiled as ‘Improvement’, warning that Stephenson's End of Life Choice Amendment Bill would dismantle important safeguards and expose more vulnerable New Zealanders to euthanasia.
The bill incorporates recommendations from the Ministry of Health's three-year review, alongside changes proposed by Stephenson himself.
As outlined earlier, the Ministry's review identified significant weaknesses in the existing safeguarding and oversight framework. Yet some of the proposed legislative changes would expand access to euthanasia rather than address those deficiencies.
Voice For Life identified several particularly dangerous areas of proposed change.
1. Removing the Six-Month Prognosis Safeguard
Under the current law, a person must have a terminal illness likely to end their life within six months to qualify for assisted dying.
Stephenson's bill proposes removing this time restriction entirely, replacing it with a requirement that the person have a diagnosed condition, or combination of conditions, that is advanced, progressive and expected to cause death.
Voice For Life warned that this would dramatically widen the group of people potentially eligible for euthanasia.
Waikato Hospital palliative-care specialist Dr Lara Hoskins, who has more than 25 years of experience caring for dying patients, warned that the greatest impact could fall on frail elderly people.
“The biggest group that would become eligible due to this criteria is the frail, elderly. Often they are the very ones isolated, lonely, and feeling they are a burden.”
Hoskins also warned that a large proportion of hospital patients could potentially satisfy the proposed medical criterion.
2. Forcing Healthcare Facilities to Accommodate Euthanasia
The proposed legislation would also undermine the ability of hospices, aged-care providers and other healthcare facilities to refuse euthanasia on their premises.
Under the changes, facilities would be required to provide reasonable on-site access to euthanasia in specified circumstances, even where the organisation conscientiously objects.
This would affect public and private hospitals, hospices, rest homes, residential aged-care facilities, and other care providers.
At the time of Voice For Life's investigation, 30 of New Zealand's 31 hospices did not allow euthanasia to be administered within their facilities.
Hospice NZ chief executive Wayne Naylor strongly opposed the proposed changes.
“Hospice NZ is a firm supporter of conscientious objection both by individuals and organisations.”
Naylor described organisational conscience protections as a foundational aspect of the existing legislation and criticised the Ministry of Health's recommendations.
3. Allowing Doctors to Suggest Euthanasia
One of the original safeguards in the End of Life Choice Act is that healthcare professionals cannot initiate a discussion about assisted dying. The patient must raise the subject themselves.
Stephenson's bill would remove this prohibition in specified circumstances, allowing doctors to introduce euthanasia during discussions about treatment and end-of-life care.
Voice For Life warned that this would fundamentally alter the relationship between patients and their healthcare providers.
A person experiencing serious illness, disability, depression or emotional distress could be presented with euthanasia as an option by the very professional they have approached for treatment and support.
The investigation highlighted disturbing examples from Canada, where assisted dying has been raised with vulnerable patients.
These included former Paralympic athlete Christine Gauthier, who testified about being offered assisted dying while seeking disability assistance, and Kathrin Mentler, who was offered information about assisted dying while seeking psychiatric help for suicidal thoughts.
4. Normalising and Promoting Euthanasia as Healthcare
Another major concern identified by Voice For Life was the proposal to increase public information and promotional material about euthanasia throughout healthcare and community settings.
The changes would support wider distribution of information through materials such as posters, pamphlets and other resources.
Voice For Life warned that presenting euthanasia as a routine healthcare option would expose more vulnerable people to messages promoting assisted death, including those seeking help for physical illness or psychological distress.
Government resources should instead prioritise healthcare and palliative care.
The Political Stakes
The proposed changes are not yet law. However, with the 2026 general election determining the makeup of the next government, the threat of further euthanasia expansion has taken on renewed political significance.
ACT has made weakening the existing restrictions on assisted dying a clear policy priority. With National potentially relying on ACT's support to form the next government, Stephenson's proposed changes could become part of coalition negotiations.
This presents a concerning possibility: safeguards that were central to the legislation New Zealanders voted on in 2020 could be placed on the negotiating table as part of an agreement to form a government.
Voice For Life's investigation warned that there could be sufficient parliamentary support for the changes. Former National MP and Family First spokesman Simon O'Connor expressed concern that Stephenson's proposals could ultimately pass through Parliament.
With ACT potentially holding significant negotiating power in the formation of the next government, the danger is that changes weakening euthanasia safeguards could be advanced through coalition negotiations, rather than waiting for Stephenson's member's bill to progress through the ballot.
The coming weeks could therefore prove critical in determining whether New Zealand's existing euthanasia safeguards remain intact or become bargaining points in the formation of the next government.
“New Zealand should not be expanding euthanasia. We should be questioning why we ever accepted intentionally ending human lives as a solution to suffering,” says Voice For Life president Lydia Posthuma.
Help us make sure these concerns are not ignored.
Share this investigation, speak to your local MP, and stand with Voice For Life in defending the value of every human life.